Christopher Cook

Democracy in the 21st Century Might Surprise You


A prediction for the 21st century: Globally, the definition of "democracy" will change so dramatically you'll no longer recognize it.

Propaganda aside, most Americans know that democracy in the US is broken. Rarely do even half the citizens vote. Those who vote choose between two candidates (a Democrat, a Republican) who each represent institutional (corporate) interests. The highest bidder (most expensive campaign) invariably wins. It's a money transaction.

Is that democracy? Well, sort of. If people define it that way. Technically, we do have a choice. If the choice sucks, it's our own damn fault. People get what they have coming, or or what they'll accept. At least that's the prevalent view.

But what about democracy elsewhere?

Most Americans do believe democracy should be spread globally. It's a noble goal ... until Islamic fundamentalists start winning elections. In Iran, for instance. And Palestine. So do we want a truly democratic Egypt? American liberals and conservatives alike confess no, if they are honest. Democracy suddenly appears insufficient on its own. Other issues matter, too, such as the separation of church and state. So we support a fake democracy in Egypt and feel relieved (if guilty) when the Egyptian government jails its fundamentalists.

Then there's the faux-democracies in some post-Soviet nations. Under the influence of Russia, these countries with one-party rule (often a group of thugs) imprison and kill dissidents, fix elections and then boast their democratic character. Americans (meaning the US government, the average American being completely ignorant on this matter) accept the pretense. After all, we want Russia as a friend. Our economy needs access to Russian oil and gas.

Indeed, the greater our economic dependence on a country, the greater our tolerance for stretching the definition of democracy -- especially if the dependence concerns energy resources. Saudi Arabia, ruled by a family oligarchy, elects a few local city councilmen (no women allowed), and we celebrate its burgeoning democracy. Not that we require such dissembling of an oil supplier. We only ask that it remain "politically stable" and keep the pipelines flowing.

On the other hand, an energy supplier that embraces democracy while opposing US policies does pose a problem. Venezuela, for instance. The US government is highly interested in seeing its populist president, Hugo Chávez, removed from office, and you can bet it's hard at work trying to accomplish that end. The same with energy-rich Bolivia, where Evo Morales, a populist and socialist, just won the presidency.

In short, it appears that Americans believe that (1) democracy is universally good and should exist everywhere; (2) democracy is bad in some countries where it does exist; and (3) democracy would be bad in some countries where it doesn't exist. About nations that merely pretend to be democracies, Americans are ambivalent (i.e., confused), especially if oil and gas supplies are concerned.

If all that seems contradictory, then welcome to the world of American foreign policy. And should you protest that I'm wrong to equate "Americans" with "US government," then I offer this reply: In a democracy, the government is of the people; it is the people.

Still, if this entire state of affairs seems bewildering, then consider the view of Plato, who more than 2,000 years ago advised against even attempting democracy. It would result, he assured us, in disaster. But then, Plato was an idealist. He didn't foresee our ability to stretch the definition of democracy to include almost anything we want it to be.

Iraq is now a democracy, because we say it is. The same for Egypt and Afghanistan and Nigeria, and Russia and Guatemala, and ... well, it's a long list. And diverse, too. In fact, you might have trouble identifying what all the nations on the list have in common other than the official claim, "We are democratic."

Just like the US.

Christopher Cook is a former journalist, union activist and author of Robbers and Screen Door Jesus. He currently lives in Prague, Czech Republic, where he's working on a screenplay.

From The Progressive Populist, March 1, 2006

Home Page

Copyright © 2006 The Progressive Populist