President-elect Barack Obama sounds progressive when he speaks about the economy, but his appointments to key economic positions raise questions about whether he is prepared to govern as one.
Lawrence Summers, in particular, who Obama plans to appoint as director of the National Economic Council, has what can best be described as a centrist if not center-right record on economic matters, advocating on behalf of NAFTA and banking deregulation during the Clinton administration.
The likely treasury secretary, Timothy Geithner, is a longtime bureaucrat and avowed political agnostic who, like Summers, is a disciple of free-trader Robert Rubin.
It is an economic team that is, as Chris Hedges wrote on Truthdig.com, heavy with the elites who created the mess.
Obama, by relying on Rubins disciples, is not offering change. He needs to radically redirect the nations resources to assist the working class and the poor, Hedges writes, or we will become a third-world country.
We will waste gargantuan amounts of money we cannot afford on our military, our national security state and bloated corporations while we damn the middle and working class to the whims, idiocy and greed of an entrenched, corporate oligarchy, he writes. Obamas appointments of Timothy Geithner as treasury secretary and Lawrence Summers as director of the National Economic Council are ominous signals that these elites remain entrenched.
At the same time, Obama is preparing to push a rather aggressive economic plan that he says will create 2.5 million jobs. During a Nov. 24 press conference announcing his economic team, Obama unveiled the broad outlines of a recovery plan for both Wall Street and Main Street, one that he says stabilizes our financial system and gets credit flowing again, while at the same time addressing our growing foreclosure crisis, helping our struggling auto industry, and creating and saving 2.5 million jobsjobs rebuilding our crumbling roads and bridges, modernizing our schools, and creating the clean energy infrastructure of the twenty-first century.
The stimulus package could carry a price tag of between $500 billion and $700 billion, according to the Washington Post, though the president-elect declined to estimate its cost.
He tasked his new team with developing recommendations with the goal of having legislation ready by the time he takes office in January.
With our economy in distress, we cannot hesitate or delay, he said.
Robert Borosage, co-director of the liberal Campaign for Americas Future, says the Obama recovery plan is far more important than the people he appoints to his administration.
Its not the personnel, its the policy, he said in a Nov. 24 statement. And on this, Obama has been clear. Hes announced a massive recovery plan based on putting people to work with public investment in areas vital to our future.
He said the economic meltdown makes Rubinomics irrelevant.
Deficit spending must go up, finance must be re-regulated, trade imbalances must be reduced and manufacturing can no longer be scorned, he said.
Obama is choosing experienced hands for the crisis, trusting that their experience does not impede the new thinking needed to get us out of this hole. Hell set the direction. And so far, hes on course.
I think he may be overly optimistic. I want to give Obama the benefit of the doubt, but he has been sending mixed signals on the economy, his obviously progressive plan being at odds with his center-right appointments. Borosage may view these experienced hands as people who get things done, and Obama may like having people around him who challenge his thinking, but by burrowing Summers so deeply into his inner circle, Obama has given one of the architects of economic crisis precious access that populists lack.
That accessas previous administrations proveis likely to result in a creeping centrism. Rubinomicswhich called for balanced budgets, deregulation and free tradetook hold in the Clinton administration even though Bill Clinton talked of enacting a small public works program as a financial stimulus during his campaign.
The only way to counteract the access and to keep Obamas eyes focused on the Keynesian approach is for progressives to press the issueby organizing and creating a momentum for public investment that will give Obama the space to take the kind of bold initiatives he has been promising. It is up to us to make sure he keeps his promises.
Hank Kalet is a poet and online editor for the Princeton Packet newspaper chain in central New Jersey. Email firstname.lastname@example.org. See his blog, Channel Surfing, at www.kaletblog.com.
From The Progressive Populist, December 15, 2008
Subscribe to The Progressive Populist