You could be forgiven for missing it in the build-up to Thanksgiving and the blizzard of impeachment news, but America’s fact-challenged chief executive was up to some old tricks this past week.
At a rally in Florida, Trump continued to peddle a false narrative that he opened an Apple plant in Texas. As the Associated Press and other outlets have reported, Trump actually visited a factory in Austin on Nov. 20 that’s been making the Mac Pro for Apple since 2013.
Nonetheless, Trump has continued to perpetuate the story, tweeting on the day of his visit that “Today, I opened a major Apple Manufacturing plant in Texas that will bring high-paying jobs back to America.”
Trump’s tall tale masks something – and you’ll pardon the pun – rotten at the core about his ongoing claims that he’s rejuvenated American manufacturing. And no amount of shine he tries to put on the Apple can change that.
“Last year was the best year for American Manufacturing job growth since 1997, or 21 years,” Trump tweeted back in January. “The previous administration said manufacturing will not come back to the U.S. ‘You would need a magic wand.’ I guess I found the MAGIC WAND – and it is only getting better!”
Yes, it’s true that manufacturing did enjoy a growth spurt during the opening months of Trump’s presidency. But, as CNBC reports, thanks to the administration’s ongoing trade war, that advantage has pretty much evaporated.
And states, such as Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Michigan, which were key to Trump’s 2016 victory, have borne the brunt of it.
Manufacturing jobs in Pennsylvania have shrunk steadily, according to NPR affiliate WITF-FM. In January, a total of 569,800 people worked in manufacturing jobs in Pennsylvania. That tally shrunk by 8,400 jobs by July, and continued to decrease into September, the data showed, to about 561,700 jobs.
The picture is much the same in Ohio and Michigan, two Obama states that flipped to Trump in 2016. The Rust Belt States are now more than “six months into a steady manufacturing job decline. Indiana also has fewer factory jobs than it did in the same period of 2018,” Newsweek reported.
In addition to the job losses in Pennsylvania, Ohio has lost 2,400 factory jobs, while employers in West Virginia cut 400 mining jobs – despite Trump’s claims that he’s saved the shrinking industry.
“I don’t think that Ohio is just a lock in the Republican’s column, nor do I think that blue-collar voters are settled on who they’re likely to select,” Robert Alexander, a political scientist at Ohio Northern University, told the AP in October. “There is a lot of economic angst still in the state.”
An October poll by Franklin & Marshall College in Lancaster, Pa. uncovered a similar sentiment. While voters felt optimistic about their personal finances, only one in three respondents said the country was headed in the right direction. And only a third of respondents said Trump was doing a “good” or “excellent” job as president.
An earlier Franklin & Marshall poll found that same number (36 percent) said Trump deserved re-election, compared to 61 percent who believed it was time to change horse.
Nonetheless, Trump’s loyalists have parroted the White House’s line.
“Our economy is in far better shape than it was four years ago,” Pennsylvania Republican Party Chairman Lawrence Tabas said during a recent lunchtime appearance before a mixed crowd of policymakers and business leaders. “6.5 million jobs have been created under President Trump, 500,000 in the manufacturing industry, which was an industry that most people thought was done and dead in this country and never to be revived.”
Trump repeated the same claim about manufacturing during a speech to the Economic Club of New York, this time inflating the number of new manufacturing jobs to 600,000 positions – which is 25% more than the actual figure, according to a New York Times fact-check.
Given the White House’s current troubles, it’s no wonder that Trump’s followers are trying to put the best face they can on the manufacturing picture.
And in the key states where workers have felt the pinch the most, you might not blame voters for once again changing their minds.
John L. Micek is Editor-in-Chief of The Pennsylvania Capital-Star in Harrisburg, Pa. Email him at jmicek@penncapital-star.com and follow him on Twitter @ByJohnLMicek.
From The Progressive Populist, January 1-15, 2020
Blog | Current Issue | Back Issues | Essays | Links
About the Progressive Populist | How to Subscribe | How to Contact Us